From murderball to ‘Mericaball: Marcelo Bielsa’s departure from Leeds United has preceded the appointment of Jesse Marsch as the club’s new manager.
The former Red Bull company man, who has spent time as the head coach of the sporting franchise’s New York, Salzburg and Leipzig teams, is tasked with keeping his new troops in the Premier League after a run that has seen the Whites take just one point from their last six matches.
More importantly for us Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers, can he reinvigorate Raphinha (£6.5m) and co as FPL assets?
Ahead of Leeds’ Double Gameweek 28, we take a look at Marsch’s tactics and management style and ask what we can expect from the 48-year-old American.
THE HISTORY
After an unremarkable playing career and a stint as an assistant with the US national team, Marsch was named as the head coach of Montreal Impact in 2011.
Leading the Canadian side to a mid-place finish in their first Major League Soccer (MLS) season before departing by mutual consent, he resurfaced in the American top flight for a successful spell with New York Red Bulls. Marsch won the Supporters Shield (the annual award given to the MLS team with the best regular-season record) in his first campaign and eventually departed for Europe in 2018, enjoying a year as assistant to Ralf Rangnick at RB Leipzig.
Twice winning the league and cup double with Red Bull Salzburg in his two years in Austria, Marsch returned to Leipzig as head coach in July 2021.
He was gone five months later, with some mixed results ending in a parting of ways in December and the German outfit languishing in 11th place in the Bundesliga.
MANAGERIAL STYLE
“Evolution, not revolution” seems to be the Leeds board’s thinking behind Marsch’s appointment, which is quite apt given Bielsa’s Darwinist approach to team news.
An aggressive press and lots and lots of running were characteristics of Bielsa’s Leeds and his successor favours a similar approach, albeit with a few tweaks.
Less man-marking and more concentrated zonal coverage is one technical difference that may be greeted by a collective Partridge shrug by FPL managers but Marsch’s attitude to winning possession back high with a view to getting shots off as quickly as possible is more exciting-sounding.
“Sprinting, sprinting together, 100%. And when you win the ball, not thinking about possession but how quickly you can score a goal” – Jesse Marsch, speaking to the Coaches’ Voice in February 2021
“If you watch Marcelo Bielsa with Leeds, he is a big believer of against the ball but he does a lot of man-marking across the field.
“So, you could stop a game at any moment with Leeds when they’re against the ball and you could almost say ‘alright, every player is matched up with an opponent and they’re playing 1v1’. We call our pressing ball-orientated.
“We believe that when we attack and attack all the way and we commit to winning balls, that we’re going to outnumber opponents in spaces on the field which is going to increase our chances of winning the ball. And then, we often leave players on the opposite side of the field open.
“Then when we win balls, we’re always trying to play forward and attack, and go as aggressively and quickly as we can to goal, because we feel that the opponent is disorganised in those moments.” – Jesse Marsch
Scoring goals and creating chances (Leeds are sixth this season for shots attempted) generally wasn’t an issue during Bielsa’s tenure but conceding them was, especially during 2021/22.
Marsch appears to be cut from the same cloth.
Salzburg scored an average of over three goals per game under the American, while even Leipzig, despite dropping to 11th in the table by the time Marsch left, found the net at a rate of two goals per match during his spell in charge.
However, Leipzig shipped 1.5 goals per fixture under the new Leeds boss in all competitions – not nearly as many as what the Whites have been letting in this season but excessive for a side that had finished second in the previous campaign.
“Looking at Leipzig’s 10-game rolling average of expected goals (xG) for and against, you can see that their chance creation remained strong after Nagelsmann’s departure, averaging chances worthy of two goals on average per 90 minutes across Marsch’s time in Germany.
“The issue was at the other end of the field, where the quality of chances conceded crept higher under Marsch. When Nagelsmann departed, Leipzig’s 10-game average was conceding chances worth just shy of one goal per game. By the time Marsch left, that number crept to closer to 1.5 xG conceded per game — a notable increase.
“This defensive output is intrinsically linked to the style of play Marsch looked to implement. When the high press works well, you can suffocate the opposition. However, if the opposition manages to play through your press, you leave space behind and risk conceding high-quality chances. – Phil Hay, the Athletic
A look at RB’s results under Marsch provides a neat summation of his managerial style: there were emphatic 6-0, 4-0 and 4-1 wins on the domestic front against strugglers Hertha Berlin, Stuttgart and Greuther Furth but a 4-1 home reverse to Bayern Munich and a 6-3 loss to Manchester City in the Champions League.
“The players really feel a power to the sense that there’s a togetherness on the pitch, tactically and mentally. And that power frees them to be their best and go after games, frees them, even in the best games against Bayern Munich or Liverpool, to show their best version of themselves.
“Now, in some of these games, we’ve given up too many goals – in almost all of them! So we’re always trying to manage our aggressiveness in the right ways. But, in the end, this is who we are. This is what I believe in.” – Jesse Marsch speaking to the Coaches Voice
MORE ROTATION?
One of the many positives about Bielsa is that he rarely handed us too many shocks when it came to naming his starting XIs, even going as far as naming his entire line-up on more than one occasion.
We might have to get used to a bit more tinkering from Marsch, however, who previously spoke of his fondness for rotation in busy periods.
“I rotate players a lot, I believe in a big roster.
“It’s important to rotate, have fresh legs, get the balance right within the team and give young players chance to play – it’s the only way they can develop.” – Jesse Marsch, speaking to the Coaches Voice
Leeds’ senior squad is on the thin side at present so, given Marsch’s comments about rotation and “giving young players a chance”, it’ll be interesting to see if Joe Gelhardt (£4.6m) can get more of a sustained look-in than he did under Bielsa, particularly with Patrick Bamford (£7.7m) out for the foreseeable future.
FAVOURED TACTICS
Having served under Rangnick at Leipzig and then adopted the Manchester United manager’s trademark 4-2-2-2 at Salzburg, there has been much talk about whether Marsch will use the same set-up at Leeds.
However, pinning him down to one system doesn’t look like it will be that straightforward.
“In my time here [at Salzburg], I have played 11 different formations, so the formations aren’t nearly as important as the fundamental habits we have within the formation.” – Jesse Marsch
Marsch ended his reign in Germany playing a 3-4-2-1/3-4-3 and given Leeds’ current defensive problems, the money might be on an extra centre-half being used – particularly as he encountered issues at the back when trying to implement his pressing game in a 4-3-3 at Leipzig.
Leeds do have more out-and-out-wingers than Leipzig, so Raphinha, Daniel James (£6.0m) and Jack Harrison (£5.5m) won’t be used to playing so narrow. The hope from an FPL perspective is that one or more of them can adapt and emulate the goalscoring exploits of Leipzig’s Christopher Nkunku, who got a lot of joy when making runs in behind the opposition defence from a number 10 role.
“The extra security without the ball apart, that [3-4-3] formation brings out of the best of Leipzig’s army of hybrid no 10s/forwards. They are all technically gifted but none of them is a true winger, and their instinct is always to move inside. When width is provided by the wing-backs they’re allowed to play closer together and, crucially, more slowly, with more precision.” – Rafael Honigstein in the Athletic
Junior Firpo (£4.7m) could be one to monitor if he emulates the attacking Angelino role from left wing-back, but FPL bosses will likely want to see an improvement in the goals conceded column before they go anywhere near a Leeds defender.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Marsch’s appointment comes at least a week too late, as we could have ideally done with seeing how his new charges will line up tactics-wise and whether they can immediately respond to fresh demands ahead of Double Gameweek 28. Given that the Leeds squad trained hard under the veteran taskmaster Bielsa, fitness at least shouldn’t be an issue with the organised press.
With so much unknown, FPL managers likely won’t take many gambles on Leeds assets for this upcoming double, aside from the semi-popular Raphinha.
But anyone using free transfers to navigate their way through Blank Gameweek 30 and beyond will be watching the matches against Leicester and Aston Villa with interest, as any fresh targets or a rejuvenated Raphinha might still be good pick-ups from Gameweek 29-32:
Ongoing injuries to key players will hamper Marsch’s efforts and his track record suggests he’s not going to tighten the defence up much.
But if he can once again get a tune out of Raphinha, whose form has nosedived since the winter break, and further boost the goal count at the other end of the pitch, most of us would settle for that.
Full-year memberships, monthly subscriptions and a FREE trial are all now available.
Join now to get the following:
- Plot your transfer strategies using the fully interactive Season Ticker.
- Get projections for every Premier League player provided by the Rate My Team statistical model.
- Use Rate My Team throughout the season to guide your selections and transfers.
- Get access to over 150+ exclusive members articles over the season.
- Analyse our OPTA-powered statistic tables specifically tailored for Fantasy Football Managers.
- Use our exclusive tool to build custom stats tables from over 100 OPTA player and team stats.
- Enjoy our Flat-Track Bully feature which introduces an opposition filter to your tables.
- View heatmaps and expected goals data for every player.
- Use our powerful comparison tool to analyse players head-to-head.
ALREADY A USER? CLICK HERE TO UPGRADE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
NEW TO SCOUT? CLICK HERE TO START A MEMBERSHIP ACCOUNT